How to Evaluate Influencers & UGC Creators by Profit, Not Views
Share
An influencer post gets 80,000 views and a few hundred likes. Was it worth the money?
Views can't answer that. Neither can engagement rate. The only way to know is to treat an influencer or UGC deal like any other way of buying customers: add up what it really cost, count the new customers it brought, and check how long they take to pay it back.
Here is a four-step framework, with one worked example from start to finish.
1. Add up the true cost (it's more than the fee)
The fee is the number everyone remembers. It is rarely the whole cost. A full influencer cost includes:
- The fee (flat, per post, or a retainer).
- Gifted product, at what it cost you, not its retail price.
- Shipping for the gifted product.
- The discount code: every order that uses the creator's code costs you the discount.
- Commission, if the deal includes a percentage of sales.
Worked example. A creator charges a $1,500 fee. You gift 20 units that cost you $15 each, plus $8 shipping each. Their 15% code is used on 60 orders with a $70 average order value.
| Cost line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Fee | $1,500 |
| Gifted product (20 × $15) | $300 |
| Gift shipping (20 × $8) | $160 |
| Discount code (60 orders × $70 × 15%) | $630 |
| True cost | $2,590 |
The $1,500 deal actually cost $2,590.
2. Count new customers, not orders
Of the 60 orders with the code, some came from people who already buy from you and simply found a discount. They didn't need the influencer. Check each code order against your customer list.
In the example, 45 of the 60 were first-time customers. So:
Cost per new customer = $2,590 ÷ 45 = $57.56
Codes miss people who saw the post and bought later without one, so this number is a cautious estimate. If you want a fuller picture, also compare new-customer orders in the two weeks after the post with the two weeks before. Use the code count as the floor and the lift as the ceiling.
3. Compare it with what a first order earns
Now the question that decides whether the deal worked: what does a new customer's first order leave you?
- Average order of $70, minus the 15% code = $59.50 paid.
- Product cost $25, shipping and payment fees $11.
- Left after the first order: $59.50 − $25 − $11 = $23.50.
Each new customer cost $57.56 and the first order brought back $23.50. You are $34 down per customer after order one.
That isn't automatically bad. A full-price repeat order leaves $70 − $25 − $11 = $34, so one more order from each customer brings the deal back to roughly even, and a third makes it profitable. Whether that is a good bet depends on how often your customers come back, and how fast. That is your CAC payback.
4. Put it side by side with your other channels
An influencer deal only makes sense next to the alternatives. If your paid social CAC is $50 and this creator came in at $57.56, the deal was a little more expensive than ads, before counting the content you got (see below). If your ads CAC is $80, it was a bargain.
Track every creator on the same four lines: true cost, new customers, cost per new customer, payback. After five or six deals you'll see which kind of creator works for your store (niche or broad, video or photo, fee or commission), and you can stop paying for reach that doesn't convert.
The Cohort LTV & CAC Payback model tracks how fast each monthly group of new customers pays back what it cost to win, so you can see whether an influencer-driven month behaves differently from the rest.
What about UGC?
UGC creators are usually paid for content you run as ads, not for posting to their own audience. So judge UGC the way you judge creative:
- Run each UGC video as an ad against your current best creative, with the same budget and audience.
- Compare cost per purchase and, if you can, cost per new customer.
- Divide the creator's fee by the number of weeks the video stays a top performer. A $400 video that carries your ads for eight weeks is cheaper than a $150 video that fatigues in one.
For how to read the test results without fooling yourself, see how to run creative and landing page tests.
The takeaway
An influencer deal is a way of buying customers. Add up the true cost, count new customers only, compare with what a first order earns, and line it up against your other channels. Views are a nice bonus, not the result.
👉 See how influencer months change your margins with the free Profit Tracker, and track payback by cohort with the Cohort LTV & CAC Payback model.